First job started....questions already!

[redrex]

Hi everyone,

Well, started at last my regrout and seal of the travertine shower area floor....3 things I learned very quickly, grout removal? DONT DO IT!! and don't forget your knee pads! and travertine IS very, very soft.

Joking aside, I and the customer are in a bit of a quandry, it seems very clear to me that the original work really wasn't completed very well (done 3 years ago), in summary the following problems are apparent....

1.Tile lipping that catches your toe as you walk over the tiles
2.Definately damp under the tiles.
3.Grout in many places only 2-3mm thick and just pushed through when raking.(10mm travertine tiles)
4.Walls move fairly easily when pushed against.
5.At least one of the tiles makes the sub floor move if you rock on it.
6.Floor tiles have not been fixed under the wall tiles at the joints therefore water runs down the wall straight to the sub floor if the sealant/grout isn't secure.
7. An underfloor heating cable is not where it should be.
8. I have looked but I just can't find a fused spur for the above-nor can the customer.
9. I really can not see any evidence of a tanking membrane, customer knows that a Wedi pre formed tray was fitted but I explained that this was mainly to get the falls to the drain ( I think I am correct on this?)
10.My knees hurt !

So having removed most of the grout, I have suggested that the only real solution is to rip up the floor and start again with a properly reinforced sub floor, tanking etc. Problem is that this is going to cost. Or as a short term fix, continue with what I am doing and use BAL admix to the grout (microcolour wide joint) absolutely packed in as much as I can and seal correctly. I have explained that this is only going to be a short term answer in particular as the shower puts out so much water that it would give the film FLOOD a run for its money. Question is...if I do an absolutely bang on job with the grouting/sealing, do I have a chance or should I get the customer to bite the bullet?

Thanks as always..

redrex

 

[White Room]

There's no quick fix for a job like that, The customer will probably spend just as much trying to repair than to redo, Bite the bullet.

 

[The D]

There is no ham in trying to repair the job as long as the customer is ok with the fact that it may not solve the problem and they may have to pay to have the whole job don correctly anyway.
If it was me I would get them to bite the bullet

 

[CJ]

My fav song for these kind of jobs :yes:

Link removed

 

[sWe]

Tell him it'll be more costly to redo everything later, rather than asap, and that water damage can spread, and cause the entire house to fester with mold. There are few things more expensive to fix than that in a house.

 

[smartile]

Trouble with fixes on unknown work is you make a rod for your back and end up never really fixing the root of the problem. Prob best to rip up and start again inc removing bottom course on walls and charge accordingly or walk away. You give your professional opinion and stick to it hard as it may be to not get roped in and think you're doing the guy a favour in helping him.

 

[basshunter]

Trouble with fixes on unknown work is you make a rod for your back and end up never really fixing the root of the problem. Prob best to rip up and start again inc removing bottom course on walls and charge accordingly or walk away. You give your professional opinion and stick to it hard as it may be to not get roped in and think you're doing the guy a favour in helping him.

quality advice.thanks smartile

 

[smurf21]

accept no responsabillity for someone elses work sounds like a never ending repair tell him to bite and bite hard

 

[MickD]

That sounds exactly like the job I've just been asked about, only it's shower room walls rather than floor. It's even in a similar area (SW London) so maybe it was the same Tiler! Also this is apparently only a 2yr old house and the builder/tiler is taking no responsibility for the workmanship.

If I take it this will be my first job too. I've not seen it yet, only talked over the phone, but I've been told that the wall is damp in the next room too.

I've already advised the customer that the tiles will need to be removed and the walls dried out and treated before tanking and fixing, but he wasn't too happy about the cost implications. However, I think I've persuaded him that the work does need doing if he doesn't want the same problem to arise.

I'll be talking to him again at the weekend so would appreciate any tips that you might give.

 

[Spud]

you will find this alot on your travels ,customers had a job done on the cheap or not so cheap and its has been totally cocked up ,they call you and expect you to turn up with a magic pot of grout which will
1. stop all movement in the substrate
2. hide all the lipping tiles
3.stop all water penetration
4 make the job look like new again
5.clean all hard water marks off the tiles
if any one finds this magic grout could you let me know oh and by the way they will not want to pay any thing for it as the 1st tiler who messed up the work has had all their money off of them ,good luck