Setting out opinion wanted

[SB4U]

Hi. This is probably a no brainer for you guys but I'm unsure of the best way to set out 300x600 tiles in a shower room that's about 2370 square. I've attached a pic for your perusal. Would you go with the top set or the bottom set? (Or something else entirely?)

The top set is with centralising a tile in the centre of the wall so that there's a pretty much equal cut on both sides. The bottom set is putting a full tile at one side which would make for a tiny trim at the other side. It seems like it would be nice to have less cuts plus there would also be only one vertical grout line on both walls in the shower area (Wall #3 and #4 on the pic.)

The vertical setting out seems to make the top of a tile line up with the bottom of the window on Wall #1 and the bottom of a tile line up with the top of the doorframe on Wall #4. Do you reckon that's a doable way of setting that out?

(The box on Wall #2 is a mirror by the way)

Steve

 

[Old Mod]

In basic terms, go for bottom setting out.
Always strive for biggest cuts possible, this makes any variation in verticals wall line less noticeable.
A window is always the very first thing u see in a room sub consciously because our eyes are drawn to the brightest source of light. So your window is of paramount importance. Get that right and most other small mistakes will go un noticed.
Yes your horizontal line, bottom of window, top of door is very possible.
When it comes to top and sides of the window if u are able to fit full tiles and have enough room in the window frame to back fill the void between the tile edge and reveal this will give a perfect window look with no cuts.
With the bottom door set out u could look at full tile from right side of door instead of left corner, this will produce a bigger cut left side of door.
But these finer details are hard to covey in a general msg like this, maybe u'd be better dealing with window and mirror wall first then come come back with more detailed pics with measurements for the other two.
If u are going to tackle one wall at a time, then be particular with the tile spacing in the corners on the horizontal plane!
Otherwise u can crush your spacers and when u tile the adjacent wall the tile joints will not meet exactly.

 

[SJPurdy]

As above, the lower drawings.
Make sure you centre on the window if possible even if it means trimming into both corners (which you should do anyway unless it is the tiniest slither of one side only).
I would recommend tiling all the walls up to the window sill line (window wall first) before going higher

 

[SB4U]

Thanks for the replies fellas.

@3_fall I'm not sure what you mean by this:

When it comes to top and sides of the window if u are able to fit full tiles and have enough room in the window frame to back fill the void between the tile edge and reveal this will give a perfect window look with no cuts.

or what you mean by crushing the spacers. Could you re-explain. Pretend you're talking to someone with a very low IQ and you won't go far wrong.

@SJPurdy I'm intrigued as to why you recommending tiling all the walls up to the window sill line rather than a wall at a time.

 

[Old Mod]

Like I say the finer points are difficult to convey but I'll try.
The reason SJ suggests tiling all the way round at the same time is that it's pretty much a fool proof way of keeping all your work level.
That's how I was taught to tile many years ago. I still do it on occasion but there's generally a specific reason other than keeping levels.
SJ is correct, definitely centre window exactly, whether it leave two fiddly nipped tiles either end. U can cover those cuts with adjacent wall tiling.
The window, we've established that u have a full tile at bottom sill.
If u can pull it up 5mm above the highest point of the sill if it's not exactly level. Don't go for spot on with the sill, u'll probably miss!
If you're slightly high when u fit the sill tile u'll get a perfect meeting of tiles.
As far as sides and top goes, from your drawing there is the smallest of cuts of the side reveals and the soffit (top)
Place a full tile on one side first (no adhesive) and see where it aligns with your window frame. If there is enough width in the frame itself before the glass u can fit full tiles, when they are set then backfill between the leading edge of the tile and the reveal effectively making a new window reveal or Soffit.
Hope that is clearer for u.

 

[SB4U]

Thanks for that. Yes, I think I get it now. Nice one.

 

[Old Mod]

No problem!
Just don't back fill completely flush!
Otherwise when u fit reveal tile it'll be proud and produce an unwanted large joint between wall tile and reveal tile.
That's bad English haha
But u get the idea I'm sure!

 

[SB4U]

Just got home from work and placed the tiles on the windowsill to check. There's actually about 40mmm gap each side with the tiles centrally positioned. So even estimating a 6mm bed under the 9mm tile that leaves about 25mm gap. Can't backfill that much because there's not enough on the window frame. Would you still go with the bottom set of drawings for the window wall with that in mind?

 

[Old Mod]

Well it's even more important to keep the window centralised then, I feel.
With small pieces like that they would be exaggerated if it was not centred.
Yes I personally would still go with bottom set of drawings, aesthetically as u walk in the room, the window wall will look correct.
And the small cut at the sill edge won't be noticeable enough to make it look unsightly, unfortunate yes, but sacrifices nearly always have to be made somewhere.
But the final finish is purely subjective anyway, what I like certainly won't be to the taste of some others, and that's a fact!
The reason I know this is because given the choice, I would outlaw the production of anything resembling a Metro Tile!
So it falls on you ultimately to make that choice, but I feel that the majority of fixers would opt for the bottom drawings, regardless of the small cut in the window.
Make life a little easier by cutting the small piece in first and cut the reveal tile on to it, even though it may be a full tile.

 

[cassie]

Bottom drawings all day long mate. It's always good to ask if you don't know. Don't fear what you don't know. Remember FEAR is: False Evidence Appearing Real. Forget FEAR! If you're local to me pop in fro a free class. the offer still stands.