Lippage clips... charge or not?

[AOS TIling]

View attachment 92584

I have also done many plank jobs with no clips, and no lips, but that was with planks that are not bowed, as I'm sure your tiles weren't bowed either other wise you would have lips! Clips can bend bowed planks back to straight to remove lips. Also, for large format tiles, there is essential. Have you not used them before ?

Correct, I worked with quality tiles - no bowing. Your answer on the bowed plank effect makes sense. It's the first time anyone has offered me a reasonable explanation as to why clips might be used. On the few occasions that I have asked, I've been shouted down. If you are referring to large, large format - no it's not a markert I have any intention entering - not for me, I've done my time. But I can understand their uses there. Mostly Victorian work for me over the last few years. But back to my comments about the clips. I see them sitting in prominent retail positions at the likes of CTD and I do fear the impact they may have on the trade. Plus there's the solid bed fixing issue on floors but that's another story. One prominent retailer said to me - 'yep, you are right to be worried about solid bed fixing but why should I care' - he was loaded with booze at the time

 

[Flintstone]

Pulling tiles up leaving voids? That is another myth

 

[One Day]

Andrew, you and me have had this discussion since the lash clips first appeared many years ago and like you I was not sold on them one bit. The early ones from Genesis and QED had curved based which did indeed pull the tiles up out of the adhesive.
I had a dabble and then went back to thinking they were diy trickery, enabling a great looking job with spot fixing.
Role on a few years and I had 300sqm of extremely expensive porcelain and a customer who insisted on absolute perfection and a very tight turnaround.
I tried RLS clips and believe me, after a few hours finding my feet with them (and some constructive insults from Antonio) I nailed it.
They saved me a heap of time, stress and mess lifting tiles to re-bed.
I checked the floor was ok, back-skimmed the tiles as usual and used a 12mm notch with wet-ish adhesive. No coverage issues (RLS have flat backs) and a 100% perfect job.
Now I don't use them on every floor, but there are times when they are very useful and speed the job up.
As for tile quality, I had some £75 a metre mandarin stone planks - 1600x250, in January. For that money I expect flat tiles but these were bowed. Without the clips, I wouldn't have managed any more than a 200mm overlap.

I admit the risk remains;
Cons: they can allow idiots to achieve a good looking job.
Pros: they can allow pros to achieve more in less time.

 

[One Day]

I should add: last month I fitted 1200x800 porcel-thin on walls and floor.
I found the clips to be absolutely essential.
Course, we could argue that perfect floors and perfect walls would negate the need for clips, but 2 main things here:
1) We never get perfect substrates.
2) Even when we do (because we prepare them) the adhesive as it cures can pull and push the levels on the large-format thin porcelain.

 

[Spare Tool]

The pool surround I've just finished would be absolutely impossible to achieve a perfect finish without clips, managed a three way fall without envelope cuts using 1200x200 planks, it literally would have been impossible without them...

 

[AOS TIling]

I'd absolutely trust your judgement Mark but seeing how they are positioned by the tills, the cons should raise concerns. I am ensuring that I won't be affected by targeting a specific market but I am no less convinced that there will be trouble ahead so to speak. The manufacturers / retailers will have only one thing in mind - sales. Maybe there should be a control of sale law applied to them

 

[Flintstone]

The pool surround I've just finished would be absolutely impossible to achieve a perfect finish without clips, managed a three way fall without envelope cuts using 1200x200 planks, it literally would have been impossible without them...

Where's the photos Andy ???

 

[One Day]

I'd absolutely trust your judgement Mark but seeing how they are positioned by the tills, the cons should raise concerns. I am ensuring that I won't be affected by targeting a specific market but I am no less convinced that there will be trouble ahead so to speak. The manufacturers / retailers will have only one thing in mind - sales. Maybe there should be a control of sale law applied to them

aah there's always going to be trouble ahead! How we position ourselves, and maintain a reputation will carry us through unscathed.
The main casualty will be the industry as a whole. In much the same way as people are very wary of tiling bathroom floors, and are becoming jaded with leaky, failed wet rooms, they could get disillusioned with tiling as a whole if failure rates shoot up, thanks to poor fixing practise...

 

[Italy]

is the same situation, as when they arrived tile adhesives.
(Now all can lay tiles)
In 2017, find still placards who say,
Leveling clips do not serve,
Yes, they do not serve for tiles up to 30x60. Maybe we would need it
of refresher courses. Otherwise you are likely to be overtaken by apprentices.

 

[AOS TIling]

Now Mark & Lee - you wonder why I don't frequent Forums too often? People who know nothing about me or my work coming out with stuff like this. As Bill O'Herlihy used to say (Irish members will know him),
'we'll leave it there'