Polypipe Overlay System

[jonnyc]

Yet another job to quote for over this system.
Polypipe must have sold thousands of these systems but talk to their technical department and the tech guys just do not a have a clue ?
After a lot of research I find that Schluter suggest that you need to apply a minimum 5mm latex cover over top of boards and pipes and then ditra will help tiles not cracking but absolutely not guaranteed .
This is the best advice I've found .
Polypipe just say you can stick tiles directly on to boards with a flex ahesive . Their tech department admitted that they have never asked an adhesive company to test their product.
What a joke !!
I am going to write to polypipe and invite them on to this forum to explain why their system is fine to fix tikes on to!,,,,,,

 

[jonnyc]

Sorry to forgot to qualify that I have found a guaranteed method over polypipe overlay boards .
Need to use min 6mm hardie backer or similar but it has to be screw fixed in to gypsum boards. This is ok if you have whole subfloor in gypsum boards. But in this instance I have a new screed with water pipes meeting the polypipe overlay . This is not uncommon with extensions. Take out bridging different substrates which isn't guaranteed but hardie board is not guaranteed either over screed unless it is mechanically fixed which means drilling maybe in to water pipes!!!!

 

[Old Mod]

Sorry to forgot to qualify that I have found a guaranteed method over polypipe overlay boards .
Need to use min 6mm hardie backer or similar but it has to be screw fixed in to gypsum boards. This is ok if you have whole subfloor in gypsum boards. But in this instance I have a new screed with water pipes meeting the polypipe overlay . This is not uncommon with extensions. Take out bridging different substrates which isn't guaranteed but hardie board is not guaranteed either over screed unless it is mechanically fixed which means drilling maybe in to water pipes!!!!

Yeah that's the method I used for Petes friend Jonny. 6mm Hardie over the Polypipe.

 

[jonnyc]

Did I recommend you do that?
Seems the best way and can't do any harm to fix ditra on top

 

[Dan]

You mentioned this on our plumbing forum?

If not, I'll start a thread and see what they're being told maybe?

 

[Old Mod]

Did I recommend you do that?
Seems the best way and can't do any harm to fix ditra on top

No I did some research with Polypipe and Ditra myself, and between all the phone calls that's what was settled on.
You did give me the tip on the latex tho

 

[Old Mod]

You know @jonnyc after sleeping on it, I'm not even sure where the original idea came from.
I know I spoke at length with Polypipe and Schluter, I found out from Polypipe that their system was a loose lay system and that they wouldn't advocate the use of latex directly over their pipes, it would have to have a covering first. All Schluter wanted was a solid load bearing substrate, and as long as I could fill both criteria then all in the world was good!
So because the Polypipe was so poorly laid I had to mechanically fix through Polypipe boards to the screed, then we fixed directly thro both the Hardie and Polypipe, carefully of course. Hence all the lines drawn on the floor in the image.
This satisfied Polypipe that there was no liquid product encasing their pipes and we could latex, this in turn gave a solid load bearing substrate which appeased Schluter! Happy days!
I also know u and I spoke on the phone about this particular job also, both before and during.
So as to exactly where the idea of using Hardie first came from is a little blurred after all this time.
So maybe it was idea u had, If it was, then oooops sorry
I see Tracy (Petes Friend) every now and then and I've to go back and put some more work right that she suffered from the original contractor, and everything is absolutely fine, I've even extended the floor in to the new play room.
So yeah, it definitely appears to work.

 

[Lee@emctiles]

oh i do love a good polypipe thread.....

kept me entertained on forums for years.....

ive asked them (and others makes) to come and chat various times, even tweeted them get them to answer Qs.

alas, nothing.

 

[Lee@emctiles]

To add, it does my head in when customers come in and explain that they can tile directly onto this type of board.

you cant.

 

[widler]

I did , a couple of years ago , tiled straight to it , was round the other month ,twas fine ,maybe the island is holding it down